Both come from the moon, but they don't keep the same time. A solunar major period is pinned to the moon passing overhead. The tide at your spot reaches high water some fixed while after that, and the delay is different everywhere. So at one spot a major period lands on a running tide, and at another it lands on dead slack.
The delay has a name
The time between the moon passing overhead and the next high tide at a place is called the lunitidal interval. It's set by the shape of the coast and the basin, and it's roughly constant for a given spot. At some stations it's an hour or two. At others it's most of a tidal cycle. That's why "the fish bite when the moon is overhead" can be true at one dock and useless at the next.

How to read the picture
Both panels have the same moon overhead and the same major period, the gray band. At Station A the high tide shows up about three hours after the moon. That delay is the lunitidal interval, and it puts the major right on the steep, moving part of the curve. At Station B the high comes with the moon, so the major sits on top of the curve, at slack. Same table, very different fishing. That's why you check the tide card, not just the solunar times.
That's really what people are after when they look for a moon tide chart: the moon's times and the tide's times on one page, so you can see where they line up.
Which one to trust
In saltwater, when the two disagree, go with the tide. Moving water moves bait, and that's the most dependable reason fish feed when they do. A solunar major that falls on slack water is a lot less interesting than one that falls on the middle of a falling tide.
The best case is when they agree: a major period in the first couple of hours of a strong tide, around the new or full moon. If you can fish that with decent weather, do.
How to line them up
On any station page:
- Check the call first. If it's Poor, none of this matters.
- Look at the tide card for when the water's moving: the steep parts of the curve, an hour or so after each high and low.
- Look at the solunar times under "Moon and bite times".
- Where they overlap in daylight, that's your window.
Tide strength helps too: on a Strong or Very strong day the moving parts move harder. See tide strength.
Freshwater and the Great Lakes
With no tide to speak of, the solunar periods are all you've got from the moon. Wind, light and water temperature usually matter more.
More: solunar tables, explained and tides and fishing.
Source: NOAA CO-OPS glossary, lunitidal interval.
Last reviewed 2026-11-15.