Learn the tides / Solunar theory: where it came from and what holds up
Learn the tides

Solunar theory: where it came from and what holds up

Solunar theory says fish and game feed hardest when the moon is overhead, underfoot, rising or setting. It was put together by John Alden Knight, an outdoor writer, in the 1920s and published in the 1930s, and it's been printed in newspapers and fishing magazines ever since. Whether it works is still argued about on every dock in America.

Where it came from

Knight collected old fishing lore, including the idea that the moon's position mattered, and his own records of when fish bit. He built tables from the moon's daily schedule and named them solunar, for sun and moon. They caught on because they were simple and gave you something to plan around.

Solunar periods and the tide over one day: Major windows when the moon is overhead or underfoot, Minor windows at moonrise and moonset, and the high tide arriving about three hours after the moon passes overhead

How to read the picture

The picture is one sample day at one spot. Up top is the moon: it rises a little before 4 AM, passes overhead just before 10, sets around 4 PM and passes underfoot a little after 10 at night. The two wide gray bands are the major periods, about two hours each, centered on overhead and underfoot. The two narrow ones are the minor periods, about an hour each, centered on moonrise and moonset. The fish mark when solunar theory says they should be feeding.

Down below is the tide at the same spot, and it doesn't keep the moon's schedule. Here the high comes about three hours after the moon passes overhead. That delay is set by the shape of the coast, so it's different everywhere: an hour or two at some stations, most of a tide cycle at others. So a major period can land on moving water at one dock and on dead slack at the next. Tides vs solunar tables explains why.

Do solunar periods work? What the evidence says

It's mixed, and honestly thin. Some studies of catch records have found small effects tied to moon phase or position for some species in some places; others have found nothing. A lot of the support is anecdote, which is the kind of evidence that remembers the good days and forgets the slow ones. Nobody has shown the moon's position alone reliably predicts a bite across waters and species.

The moon's effect nobody argues about

The moon definitely moves fish around in saltwater, through the tide. It decides when the water moves and how hard, and moving water moves bait. On the days around new and full moon, the tides are biggest and the current strongest, and those are also the days solunar tables rate highest. It's hard to separate the two, and a lot of what people credit to solunar timing may really be tide timing. Tides vs solunar tables goes into that.

Our take

Use it as a tiebreaker, not a plan. If you're picking between two mornings with the same weather, sure, take the one with a major period on a moving tide. Don't drive two hours into a 20-knot wind because the table says the fish are hungry. That's why solunar times are on every station page and never in the call.

How to read the table itself: solunar tables, explained.

Last reviewed 2026-11-15.